AI visibility7 min read
ByKarol PiaseckiFounder TextRank.ai
Published
Reading time7 min read
Updated

Good content, no ChatGPT mentions. Which agency can help?

Evaluate an AI visibility agency through buyer questions, recorded answers, cited sources, specific content changes and a clear measurement scope.

You publish useful guides and your product solves a real problem, yet ChatGPT names competitors when someone asks which provider to choose. An agency promises to fix your visibility. Before comparing names, establish what that agency will investigate, change and deliver.

Choose an agency that can connect a buyer question to a recorded answer, available sources and a justified change to your page. A promise of more mentions is difficult to evaluate without a measurement method. A package of ten articles is equally hard to assess without an explanation of why those articles are needed.

Define what is missing from the answer

A brand mention, a product recommendation and a page citation are different events. An answer can name your company while advising against it for a particular use case. It can also link to your guide without naming your brand in the main response.

Peec AI explicitly distinguishes brand visibility from source usage. Its documentation explains that a website can appear as a source without its brand appearing in the answer. This is a vendor's explanation of its metrics, not evidence that any particular campaign works. Peec AI's explanation.

Write down the result you need before speaking to an agency. If buyers cannot understand your migration conditions, you need accurate migration information. If you want to know whether your company enters product comparisons, you need observations of selection questions. Both can belong in one project, but they need separate acceptance criteria.

Ask for an assessment of one buying question

Instead of starting with “best CRM,” choose a question tied to an actual purchase decision. Suppose you sell a CRM for small teams and prospects regularly ask whether they can import contacts and history from spreadsheets without a consultant. That gives the agency a specific starting point: your migration page, import documentation and support conditions.

The agency should record the exact prompt, language, platform, date and collection method. It should then show the available sources and distinguish what those sources demonstrate from what the analyst infers. If the answer reveals no sources, the report should preserve that limitation rather than invent a reason for the model's choice.

A useful task might be: “The migration page lacks supported fields, history restrictions and plan requirements. The product owner will confirm them, and the writer will add the approved information beside the import instructions.” An instruction to “improve authority” does not provide an equivalent basis for action.

Seven questions to ask an AI visibility agency

  1. Where do the questions come from? Customer conversations, search data and an analyst's suggestions have different evidence behind them. A proposed prompt is not automatically confirmed demand.
  2. What do you measure? Brand names, recommendations, cited URLs, mention order and website traffic describe different outcomes.
  3. What are the observation conditions? Request the language, market, platforms, repetitions and a record of methodology changes.
  4. Will we receive the answers and sources? You should be able to trace a number back to the material used to calculate it.
  5. What implementation is included? Separate analysis, fact gathering, writing, publication and technical changes.
  6. Who approves product claims? The agency should not invent capabilities, prices, customers or results.
  7. How will we accept the work? Define acceptance of the changes separately from observations of AI answers and business results.

Compare equivalent scopes. A lower-priced report may require a separate writer and developer, while another proposal includes implementation. Report length will not tell you which service solves your capacity problem.

Send every agency the same brief

You can make the first conversation concrete without buying a long engagement. Give each candidate the same product URL, target market, language and buying question. Include the product documentation needed to verify claims. Ask for the proposed diagnostic work, implementation scope and first deliverable.

For example, a CRM team could use this brief:

We want to understand our representation in answers about migrating contacts and sales history from spreadsheets. Assess our migration page and relevant pricing conditions. Record the questions, collection method, answers and available sources. Separate confirmed page gaps from hypotheses. Specify the edits, who verifies the facts, who publishes them and how we will observe subsequent answers.

An agency should be able to explain how it would approach that task before promising a quantity of new content. You do not need it to produce an unpaid full audit; you need a scope you can evaluate.

Evaluation criterionEvidence to request
Traceable diagnosisAn anonymized or public sample connecting a question, answer, source and recommendation
Implementation capacityNamed responsibilities for product facts, copy, technical fixes and publication
Comparable pricingAnalysis, implementation, monitoring and follow-up listed as included or separately priced
Measurement disciplineA stated question set, observation conditions and treatment of failed runs
Relevant experienceA case with the starting point, work performed, period and limits of attribution

Treat these as selection criteria, not a ranking of suppliers. A content specialist may fit when the facts are available but poorly explained. A broader agency may fit when editorial work, technical access and external information all need owners. If your team can implement the changes, a focused diagnosis may be enough.

Decide whether the constraint is technical or editorial

If an important page is inaccessible or has an indexing problem, start with technical diagnosis. Google says the usual SEO foundations remain relevant to AI Overviews and AI Mode without additional special requirements. That guidance concerns Google's features; it does not automatically describe other platforms. Google Search Central.

If the page is available but leaves buying conditions unclear, bring in a writer and a product expert. If the observed answers reference external comparisons, check the accuracy of your company's information in those publications. Another post on your own blog is not the answer to every finding.

For a broader visibility problem, use the SaaS competitive-keywords action plan. It separates diagnosis, source analysis and implementation across the first month.

How TextRank supports an agency or internal team

TextRank is a content-analysis tool. Our method connects a buyer question, a model answer, available referenced sources and the relevant passage on your page. It helps identify a missing answer, piece of evidence, concept or supporting article. The comparison includes competitors' content and terminology. TextRank's audit method.

For the migration brief, you can include up to three of your own URLs for one prompt: the migration guide, product page and pricing page. Use the available source comparison to ask whether the pages specify supported fields, history limits and plan requirements. Have your product owner confirm the answers before the writer makes changes. This gives the agency a bounded task and gives you material against which to assess its proposal.

A competitor's vocabulary provides clues about topic coverage. It is not a list of words that guarantees a recommendation. A source referenced by AI also needs factual review; its appearance is not an independent quality certificate.

An agency can work from that analysis, or your own team can implement the changes. If you need recurring monitoring across many questions, compare that scope with a page-level audit. Our top 10 AI visibility tools comparison explains the different approaches and metric limitations.

Set an outcome for the first month

The first round should produce a question set, source material, priorities and implemented changes. Each task needs an owner for the facts, a publication location and a reason. Keep a copy of the page before editing so you can compare versions later.

Observe AI answers repeatedly under documented conditions. One changed answer does not prove an agency's effectiveness, and one missing mention does not invalidate an accurate implementation. Track visits, started audits and qualified inquiries separately from mentions.

Before you commit to an agency retainer, create a TextRank account and audit the page ChatGPT should be able to use for your buyer's question. Take the available sources and proposed page changes to the agency discussion. Ask which tasks it will implement, what facts it needs from you and what the quoted fee covers. You will have a concrete brief for choosing help instead of comparing promises of more mentions.